“Sinatra Has A Cold”: New Journalism and Gay Talese

Gay Talese’s “Frank Sinatra Has a Cold,” published in April 1966,  has one of the best back stories in journalism. Talese travelled to San Francisco to interview the great music legend for a profile piece. Sinatra, approaching 50, out of popularity, growing old and suffering from a cold changed his mind and refused to be interviewed. In a great moment of lemonade making out of lemons, Talese began to instead interview everyone around Sinatra:

That night I’m sitting at a bar around ten o’clock  watching people, and sure enough I notice Frank Sinatra sitting down the corner of the bar with two blondes. Sinatra goes to play pool and I witness a scene between Sinatra and a guy named Harlan Ellison, and I write it down on a shirt board. But I don’t get it all, so I go up to Ellison and ask him if I can talk to him the next day. He gives me his phone number and address. When we speak in person I ask him not just what everyone said, but what he was thinking. I always ask people what was on their mind. Were you surprised by Sinatra? Had you met him before? Did you think he was going to hit you, or did you want to pop him?

(Gay Talese, The Art of Nonfiction No. 2, The Paris Review)

The result is a Sinatra without the Sinatra’s editorialising. We get a view of the man rather than the man Sinatra wishes to tell an interviewer he is. The whole thing becomes a vivid story about the hero’s superpower weakening (his voice), the fight against his enemies (the media) and his glorious victory. If it were not an essay it could be a play or a poem. Look how he describes Sinatra’s cold:

Sinatra with a cold is Picasso without paint, Ferrari without fuel — only worse. For the common cold robs Sinatra of that uninsurable jewel, his voice, cutting into the core of his confidence, and it affects not only his own psyche but also seems to cause a kind of psychosomatic nasal drip within dozens of people who work for him, drink with him, love him, depend on him for their own welfare and stability. A Sinatra with a cold can, in a small way, send vibrations through the entertainment industry and beyond as surely as a President of the United States, suddenly sick, can shake the national economy.

That paragraph makes me want to start the whole thing all over again.

Talese skill was to write slowly and deliberately, while knowing his subjects to such a depth that he could reliably ascribe them with thoughts and feelings rather than just words and actions.

Often a negative review is a put-down of my technique. They don’t believe me. They think I’m faking. Talese writes so-and-so was thinking this. How do we know this person was thinking that? The reason I knew is that I interviewed them over and over again.

(The Paris Review)

Gay Talese in an excellent suit

Talese’s father was tailor; his mother made dresses. Dressing well is a family tradition.

This all makes Talese a father of New Journalism – the movement to introduce unconventional techniques borrowed and stolen from fiction into journalism whilst trying to maintain journalism’s objectivity. As with most things that call themselves “New” it is rather old now. Almost every newspaper these days will have some story in it with techniques that would have once been thought of as very cutting edge New Journalism and are now readily accepted. You will seldom, however, have read  New Journalism written quite as well as this. Esquire recently named it as one of their greatest stories of all time. You can find a copy on their website. Enjoy!

This entry was posted in American, Essayists, New Journalism, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to “Sinatra Has A Cold”: New Journalism and Gay Talese

  1. Excellent analysis – I know so little about Talese but this has to be one of the best feature articles ever written. I tried to find a similar article to show my Year 9 students but could find nothing as good. Any suggestions?

  2. stephenbuggy says:

    What a nice start to my morning to get this comment!

    I’m not sure what exactly you are looking for but here is a quick stab at a few things:

    If you are looking for introductions to a range of Essayists then The Art of the Personal Essay by Phillip Lopate is the best thing out there. Cannot recommend it enough. Great selections and great introductions.

    The best analyses in detail of specific contemporary journalistic pieces is the Nieman storyboard. http://www.niemanstoryboard.org/

    The Paris Review Interviews on The Art of Nonfiction are a great way to get a sense of specific artists. But probably too long to give directly to year 9s.

    The most straightforward introduction to nonfiction form out there is probably William Zeinsser’s “On Writing Well”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s